Sound Artist Amie Slavin talks about the trials and tribulations of editing Other Ranks and how every stutter, mumble and pause must be considered.
At the end of the process of collecting sounds, I gathered them all up and began the massive labour of love, which is the editing process. I had to listen to every moment of every recording, snipping and making tidy cuts of usable sounds and filing them for inclusion in the piece. I had to spot what’s especially good and excise anything off-topic, contaminated or unusable for any other reason.
At this point I had a big pile of files, each still quite lengthy, containing the best of each location and/or voice. This is where it gets tricky…
The toughest part of editing for a project like this one is that you end up with more material than you have space. You are, if you are me, now in love with every sound, every voice, and getting really scratchy about losing anything anyone has said. Tough! Man-up, whining arty-person!
From here on, each sound file has to stand up and justify its inclusion in the piece. Every voice gets edited further as each one is snipped and placed, with extreme delicacy and care, into position within the mix. Each must overlap its surrounding sounds correctly. A fraction of a second alters where the listener’s attention is – and this has a very real impact on which parts of which voices actually get heard. I like to have voices criss-crossing each other, like old chaps in a pub, each philosophising into his pint, they chime, coalesce and weave gently around each other. They also cut across each other, sometimes agreeing and sometimes not. They reinforce and contradict each other. One voice adds to another from a very different experience or perspective.
Throughout the process, my preference is to preserve the participant’s own speech rhythms and style of articulation. I don’t like to begin by cutting out their stumbles and stutters. I like the emotional elaboration we get from the way someone speaks, as well as the words they say.
At every point the priority is to pay central attention to what each person was trying to say. I warned participants that their voices would be edited. I also promised to represent them fairly. This was a most serious and sincere pledge and, at the end of the production process I am equally concerned with how each participant will feel about his treatment within the edits and the piece, as well as the effectiveness of the whole mix. This creates an additional complexity which has served to keep me awake and pacing the floor through many nights in the past four years.
The end product contains literally hundreds of sounds and dozens of voices, as well as several hundred participants who contributed their marching feet and PT exertions. In many places the voices are edited into fluency. Many, are of course, fluent to begin with. Where necessary, I have removed stumbles and mumbles, which make a particular piece of speech too long for the gap it’s heading for. Did it work? Well that’s your call, isn’t it?
Blogger: Amie Slavin
Other Ranks is now open in the War Gallery at Royal Armouries Museum in Leeds until March 2013. For more information, visit our website.